Expert Recommendation
.Overview
With a huge zoom reach, rapid-fire continuous shooting, lightning-fast focus speed, and the best high-ISO ability around, the Canon Rebel XSi is a phenomenal camera that packs just about every tool you need to produce great fast action photos in even the most difficult conditions.
My Best In Class Pick
Canon EOS Digital Rebel XSi (Body Only)
Though it’s part of Canon’s “entry-level” Rebel series of cameras, don’t be fooled - the Rebel XSi is a full-featured SLR that features best-in-class image quality and all the tools you need to take great fast action photos in even the most demanding situations.
High ISO quality on the Rebel XSi is the best in its class, producing extremely clean photos while freezing the motion of fast action subjects in even the darkest situations. While the Rebel XSi comes with an 18-55 kit lens, fast-action photography requires a long telephoto lens, so a better choice would be the Canon 75-300, which provides a 120-480mm zoom range (this is equivalent to about a “14x zoom” on most consumer cameras), that allows you to zoom in for great close-up shots. The lens aperture is f4-5.6, which is about average for a budget telephoto lens.
The Rebel XSi features a comprehensive 9-point autofocus system, which should adequately cover and track most subjects as they move around the frame. Unlike most budget lenses, Canon’s 75-300 uses an ultrasonic motor (USM) for autofocus rather than the conventional micro-motor or screw-driven motor found on other cameras and lenses - this allows the 75-300 to focus far faster when tracking moving subjecs.
The Rebel XSi can take photos continuously at 3.5 frames per second, for up to 53 photos. This will let you capture long bursts of action, allowing you to choose the precise moment or best shot afterwards. With a near-instant shutter lag, the Rebel XSi shouldn’t have any problems reacting quickly or precisely timing shots.
Comparison with Pentax K200D (with 18-55mm Lens)
While the K200D has an even better autofocus system than the Rebel XSi, the Canon camera beats out the K200D in all the other performance categories - focus will be faster with the ultrasonic motor lens, the faster and longer continuous shooting will get you more keepers, and the great high-ISO performance means images will already be noise-free straight out of the camera.
Comparison with Nikon D40 (with 18-55mm and 55-200mm Lenses)
Though they’re both billed as entry-level cameras, the D40 and Rebel XSi are quite different beasts - the D40 provides decent high-ISO quality for freezing action, but beyond this only offers basic functionality, while the Rebel XSi offers even better high-ISO, a longer lens, faster shooting, and a much more capable autofocus system.
Pros
- +Superb high-ISO
- +Comprehensive 9-point autofocus system
- +Fast 3.5 fps continuous shooting
- +Fast USM autofocusing
Where to buy
Canon EOS Digital Rebel XSi (Body Only)
- Amazon.com : $569.99
- DBROTH : $560.99 (Best Price)
- Compare Prices : $560 - $1103
Recommended with
-
Canon EF 75-300mm f/4-5.6 III Telephoto Zoom Lens for Canon SLR Cameras$141.66 @ Amazon.com
- Highly Recommended at DPReview.com
- Dave's Pick at Imaging-Resource.com
- Rated Very Good by CNET.com
Comparing My Best In Class Pick with Other Good Choices
| Product |
![]() |
2
![]() |
3
![]() |
|
| Customer Rating |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
(from 213 reviews)
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
(from 67 reviews)
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
(from 414 reviews)
|
|
| Price | $560 - $1103 | $555 - $1056 | $589 - $699 | |
| Size (W x H x D) | 5.1 x 3.8 x 2.4 in. | 5.2 x 3.7 x 2.9 in. | 5.0 x 3.7 x 2.5 in. | |
| Weight (without batteries) | 16.8 oz | 22.2 oz | 16.6 oz | |
| Max Shooting Speed (continuous) | 3.5 frames/sec | 2.8 frames/sec | 2.5 frames/sec | |
| Max Consecutive Burst Frames | 53 | 4 | Unlimited | |
|
?
Close
Min Focal Length (35 mm equivalent)
The 35 mm equivalent focal length is a measure that indicates the angle of view of a particular combination of a camera lens and the sensor size. The term originates from the time when the vast majority of photography was done with 35 mm film. On any 35 mm film camera, a 30 mm or less lens is considered a wide-angle lens.
|
29 mm | 27 mm | 27 mm | |
|
?
Close
Max Focal Length (35 mm equivalent)
The 35 mm equivalent focal length is a measure that indicates the angle of view of a particular combination of a camera lens and the sensor size. The term originates from the time when the vast majority of photography was done with 35 mm film. Larger max focal lengths make distant objects appear more magnified.
|
480 m | 450 mm | 300 mm | |
| Optical Zoom | 15.9x | 16.7x | 11.1x | |
|
?
Close
Image Stabilization Available
Image stabilization features are designed to reduce the blur that results from normal, minute shaking of a lens due to hand-held shooting. However, image stabilization does not prevent motion blur caused by the movement of the subject or by extreme movements of the camera.
|
No | Yes | No | |
|
?
Close
Max Aperture (wide-angle)
The aperture refers to the size of the opening in the lens that determines the amount of light falling onto the sensor. The maximum aperture (wide-angle) is the largest possible size at the wide-angle limit of the zoom lens. The lens aperture is usually specified as an f-number, the ratio of focal length to effective aperture diameter. A lower f-number denotes a greater aperture opening, which allows more light to reach the image sensor.
|
f/4 | f/4 | f/4 | |
|
?
Close
Max Aperture (tele-photo)
The aperture refers to the size of the opening in the lens that determines the amount of light falling onto the sensor. The maximum aperture (tele-photo) is the largest possible size at the tele-photo limit of the zoom lens. The lens aperture is usually specified as an f-number, the ratio of focal length to effective aperture diameter. A lower f-number denotes a greater aperture opening, which allows more light to reach the image sensor.
|
f/5.6 | f/5.6 | f/5.6 | |
| Battery Life | 500 shots | 550 shots | 470 shots | |
| Important fast action features | ||||
| Shutter lag | Superb | Superb | Superb | |
| High ISO quality | Superb | Good | Good | |
| Autofocus rating | Superb | Good | Poor | |
| Fast action rating | Superb | Good | Average | |
Pentax K200D (with 18-55mm Lens)
The K200D is a versatile and feature-rich camera produced by Pentax. Though some of its features, like weather-seals for rain/dust, aren’t strictly useful for fast action, the K200D offers good image quality and most of the tools needed to produce good action photos.
High-ISO on the K200D is good - although images tend to be grainier than other cameras, they retain detail remarkably well. With noise reduction software, the K200D images can look as detailed and clean as any other model on the market. With an additional Tamron 70-300 lens providing a 105-480mm zoom range, the camera has more than enough reach to shoot the far away subjects like a race car on a distant track or players on the other side of a field. The lens aperture is f4-5.6, about average for a budget telephoto. The K200D also offers a sensor-shift image stabilization system which helps to combat camera shake blur, especially at the long end, but this usually won’t be useful at the faster speeds used in action photography.
With a very comprehensive 11-point autofocus system that features 9 extra-sensitive “cross-type” points, the K200D is more than capable of tracking any moving subjects. Its Tamron 70-300 lens uses a slower micro-motor autofocus, though, so it may have trouble keeping up with extremely fast subjects.
The K200D can takes photos at a decent 2.8 frames per second, but can only sustain this for 4 frames, good for a little more than a second of action. While this isn’t nearly long enough to cover a long series, the short bursts still help to give you more options to choose from for the best shot or timing. With a short shutter lag time, the K200D shouldn’t have any problems snapping off shots at an instant.
Comparison with Nikon D40 (with 18-55mm and 55-200mm Lenses)
Because of the D40’s severe limitations in key areas like autofocus, the K200D is the better overall camera, offering a longer zoom reach and a much more capable autofocusing system that is essential to capturing good action images. The D40 has a few advantages, however - its continuous shooting can take photos at 2.5 fps indefinitely, compared to the four photos that the K200D can snap in a row. The D40 also has slightly better high-ISO images - although images won’t be as detailed as the K200D, they’ll have less visible noise out-of-the-box.
Pros
- +Good, detailed high-ISO, but slightly grainy
- +Very comprehensive 11-point autofocus system
Cons
- -Slower micro-motor focusing
- -Continuous shooting limited to 4 photos
Where to buy
Pentax K200D (with 18-55mm Lens)
- Amazon.com : $564.99
- Willoughby's Establi… : $555.00 (Best Price)
- Compare Prices : $555 - $1056
Recommended with
-
Tamron AF 70-300mm f/4.0-5.6 Di LD Macro Zoom Lens for Pentax Digital SLR Cameras$153.79 @ Amazon.com
Nikon D40 (with 18-55mm and 55-200mm Lenses)
Nikon’s entry-level D40 offers most of the basic functionality of a DSLR, although it lacks some of the more advanced features commonly found in other cameras.
High-ISO quality on the D40 is good - images are clean straight from the camera, atlhough they’re somewhat blotchier and don’t have quite the detail of some other cameras. The 55-200 kit telephoto lens covers a 78-300mm zoom range - enough for most fast action events, but not quite long enough to get the best up-close shots. The lens aperture is f4-5.6, typical for a budget telephoto lens.
The D40 uses a woefully-inadequate 3-point autofocus system, making it extremely hard to track anything but the slowest and most predictably-moving subjects. The 55-200 lens does feature an ultrasonic motor, allowing it to keep up with faster subjects, but this won’t be usable if the camera doesn’t have a focus point to lock onto the subject to begin with.
The D40 can shoot continuously at 2.5 frames per second for an unlimited number of photos - a little slow, but still useful for capturing long bursts of action and choosing the best shot afterward. Shutter lag is quick with the D40.
One additional downside of the D40 is lens compatibility - because it doesn’t have an in-body focus motor, the D40 is incompatible with a number of lenses, including most large aperture prime lenses. For the casual snapshooter who will never buy more lenses, this isn’t a problem. If you’re interested in eventually learning more photography or eventually graduating to better equipment, however, the D40 has limited potential.
Comparison with Sony Alpha DSLR-A200 (with 18-70mm and 75-300mm Lenses)
While the D40 doesn’t have the same reach or autofocus ability of the A200, the D40 does beat the A200 in high-ISO performance, where it produces much cleaner and more detailed images. If you’re shooting often in low-light situations (indoors or at night), and your subjects aren’t moving too fast or unpredictably (baseball, for instance), the the D40 would be the better choice. However, for faster action events (rodeos or football games for example), especially in daylight situations, the A200’s much better autofocus system is essential to producing in-focus photos, and makes it the better choice.
Pros
- +Above-average high-ISO
- +Fast ultrasonic focusing
Cons
- -Only 3-point autofocus system
- -Limited room to grow with lens incompatibility
Where to buy
Nikon D40 (with 18-55mm and 55-200mm Lenses)
- Willoughby's Establi… : $589.99 (Best Price)
- Compare Prices : $589 - $699
- Highly Recommended at DPReview.com
- Dave's Pick at Imaging-Resource.com
- Rated Very Good by CNET.com
Sony Alpha DSLR-A200 (with 18-70mm and 75-300mm Lenses)
Though it doesn’t offer any unique features or spectacular performance, the Sony A200 is a decent entry-level SLR that can get the job done for fast action photography.
High-ISO performance on the A200 is below average for an SLR - although it can still produce usable images in low-light situations, they’ll tend to have lots of blotchy noise. The Sony 75-300 lens features a 105-450mm zoom range, long enough to cover even the most far away subjects. The f4-5.6 aperture is typical for a budget telephoto lens. The A200 does offer a sensor-shift IS system, although its usefulness is limited since action is often shot at higher shutter speeds anyway.
The A200 uses a 9-point autofocus system, which should cover most subjects adequately as they move around the frame. The Sony 75-300 lens uses a conventional micro-motor for autofocus, so it may have a little trouble keeping up with the fastest subjects.
The A200 can shoot at 3 frames per second for an unlimited number of photos, allowing you to snap off entire series and then choose the best shot later. Shutter lag is minimal on the A200.
Pros
- +Comprehensive 9-point autofocus system
Cons
- -Slower micro-motor focusing
- -Poor high-ISO performance
Where to buy
Sony Alpha DSLR-A200 (with 18-70mm and 75-300mm Lenses)
- Amazon.com : $549.99
- Ace Photo Digital : $549.00 (Best Price)
- Compare Prices : $549 - $749
- Highly Recommended at DPReview.com
- Dave's Pick at Imaging-Resource.com
- Rated Very Good by CNET.com
How It Works
Unbiased experts recommend the best digital camera for you based on the types of photographs you intend to take, your budget, and desired features.
Advertisement
How to Pick Digital Cameras
- For Travel Photos
- For Photos of Children or Pets
- For Action or Sports Photos
- For Photos in Low Light








